Church planter May Gere, 89, of Amazing Grace Anglican Church in Roseville, California, shares how she initially fought God when he told her to plant a church—and the surprises He had in store when she said yes.
Q. How did God call you to become a church planter?
A. For three months, every day in my prayers, God’s message to me was, “You are to start me a church.” I said, “I can’t, Lord. I’m too old.” The next day, I heard it again: “You are to plant me a church.” The Lord spoke that to me over and over. Heaven was on my heels.
Back then, Ed McNeill [of St. James Church in San Jose] was just starting to help people plant churches in Northern California. He knew me pretty well, and we had a conversation about it. I said, “I can’t do it, Ed.” He said, “Oh yes, you can. You’re going to do it.” Finally, I said yes to the Lord.
Q: At the time, you had just recently joined The Anglican Church in North America. How did you become an Anglican?
A: It was a struggle because for years, my husband Fred, an Episcopal priest, and I had both been torn apart by heretical teaching in the Episcopal church. We had a lot of help from [former ACNA Archbishop] Bob Duncan, and Fred and I both became Anglicans at the same time. Fred renounced his episcopal vows. I went to a few of the original gatherings for the ACNA in 2005 or 2006 and from that moment on, I was gung ho to be a part. Soon after, I began hearing from God about church planting.
At that point Fred and I were attending an Episcopal church in Roseville, and about 15 other people there wanted to leave as well, but had no place to go. They said, “If you’ll start a church, we’ll come.” That fall, we started a church in our house.
Q. What was your husband’s role in starting the church?
A. Fred never wanted to be a church planter. He was a retired priest, and he was tired. He said, “I’m not going to do it with you. I will be your priest, but I’m not doing any of the rest of this stuff.” I understood why. But people thought it was strange that I was the church planter, not my husband.
Q. What happened during the first few months?
A. We just persevered. Many of the friends we left behind at the Episcopal church would no longer speak to us. We met in our home for about five or six months, and then there was an opportunity to move to an empty church building in Roseville, and we felt maybe we could get some families with children to join us. But we didn’t really grow at all there.
About that time, Fred and I moved to a retirement community in Roseville—Sierra Regency. So we decided to have services here. Our church is much different than we originally thought it would be. Now we are a small congregation for people who are retired. No young people, mostly people in their 80s and 90s. We meet on Sunday afternoons because when you’re in your 80s, if you have a choice between going to church and going to brunch, you go to brunch.
Q. In what other ways has the church plant surprised you?
A. We did not expect to be a cradle for clergy coming from other denominations into Anglicanism. Fred passed away four years ago, and since then we have been having various priests assisting us. Victor Shreffler was the first. He came to us from the Nazarene Church. Josh Lichter came through us as well, and now we have a deacon named Jackie Houser, both from different denominations. We have gotten this reputation as a place to send someone who needs practice being an Anglican clergy. We still help other people get started, even out of our smallness.
Q. How do you see God using you as his instrument?
A. I’m happy to be doing what I’m doing for the Lord. I am the oldest church planter in the ACNA. I have this reputation with people who have looked up to me over the years; they call me Mother May. It’s a little embarrassing to have them call me that. I’m just a very active lay person. You name the job, I’ve done it. I’ve never been interested in being ordained. People say, “You should be ordained.” And I say, “No, the church needs lay people who can lead.” And I can do that. I’m a lay Eucharistic minister.
Q. What are your services like?
A. Our services are quite high church, but our trappings are low. We can’t have candles in the building because it’s against the rules. We occasionally use electric ones. We meet in a chapel, and we have a cross up front, and we move a table from the wall to put a cloth on. There’s not a lot of room for anything else. I’m the only person in this small congregation who has a real Anglican background. The others are Lutherans, Baptists, Congregationalists, etc., who have grown to love the Anglican tradition. We also have a Bible study on Monday and a prayer service on Friday.
Q. What’s your biggest challenge right now?
A. The challenging thing is trying to get new members. We have a number of people who live here, but many get a ride to Catholic or Presbyterian churches. Some people are not interested in church at all.
Q. What do you love most about your work at Amazing Grace?
A. I love the people. They are so devoted to Jesus Christ and to one another. They are so devoted to the people they live with, who don’t come to our services but need their loving care. We go out and lay hands on somebody if they’re not feeling well. It’s beautiful. Sometimes we get a little bit down because we’re so small, but it doesn’t matter because we’re doing what God has called us to do.
Q. What is your advice for other reluctant church planters?
A. Just listen. If God’s telling you to do it, do it. Don’t be afraid, and don’t be afraid of change. Just because he told you to do this thing this year, it might not be what he wants to do in five years. But God is in charge and he is sure growing his church.
Learn more about Amazing Grace Anglican Church.